One thing that always amazes me about the Christian Right is their refusal to debate with the gay people they are so happy to debate among themselves. I now have a new example of this. Jonathan Ekman, the director of Livets Ord, a conservative and charismatic Christian congregation in Sweden, runs a blog where he shares his ideas about theology, culture, and politics. Blog readers are invited to take part in the discussions, but everyone who has a strong argument against Ekman’s position on homosexuality is blocked.
Yesterday, I read Ekman’s posting on the Church of Sweden’s decision to allow same-sex couples to marry. The article is full of hatred and misunderstandings. A number of highly homophobic readers—probably from Ekman’s own congregation—have commented on the blog article. But one in particular had a straightforward question I decided to answer.
It is common that Christian homophobes try to mock the fact that gay people are legally and culturally considered a group of people, much like an ethnic group. This, the Christian homophobes say, is political correctness and something the gay lobby has created to gain power in society. The reader on Ekman’s blog asked rhetorically, “When did people become groups based on sexual preferences?”
This question—which is repeated over and over by people who assume the obvious answer is that the homosexuals have done this themselves—is in fact easy to answer.
In 1230, Pope Gregory IX wrote a document that for the fist time made homosexuals a distinct group of people. In earlier documents, homosexuality had been described as simply an action—most often anal intercourse. But as from 1230, the Catholic Church treated gay people as a group much like an ethnic group. During the Spanish Inquisition, gay people and Jews were singled out as the two groups that should be exterminated. Both gays and Jews were tortured and burned at the stake simply for being members of these groups. Since then, gays have been treated as a group of people in legal matters in many countries, and in the 1930s, the Nazis forced gay people to wear pink triangles.
It was the homophobes, not the homosexuals, that made gay people the legally and culturally defined group of people it is today.
This was the dangerous information that Jonathan Ekman could not allow on his blog. I know why. It would take away one opportunity to discredit gay people. Better then to ignore the facts and refuse an informed gay person a voice.
Update at 23:15: Jonathan Ekman has now published my comments on his blog.