
No man is more associated with religious homophobia than full-time propagandist Fred Phelps of the Westboro Baptist Church. He is best known for picketing funerals and harassing mourning families. The man claims to preach the Bible, but after I noticed the reference to Romans 9:13 in the picture above, I think any such claim can be refuted.
I looked up Romans 9:13 and found this:
Just as it is written: “Jacob I loved, but Esau I hated.”
Where is the proof of God’s hate of gay people in that sentence? I understand that Paul refers to the story of Jacob and his older brother Esau, but where does that include homosexuality? I know some modern theologians say that Jacob’s nightlong wrestle with God and God’s subsequent blessing of Jacob could be understood as a blessing of the unique love between men. But somehow, I doubt Phelps thought of that. So I search the Internet for information on Esau, and found this:
Esau was the eldest son of Isaac and Rebekah, and Jacob’s older twin brother. As firstborn Esau had a birthright to a double share of inheritance, but he sold this birthright to Jacob for a bowl of stew. Esau was a skillful hunter and Isaac’s favorite son. When Isaac was near death he asked Esau to bring him a meal of wild game and then Isaac would bless him. While Esau hunted, Jacob disguised himself as Esau, brought food, and received a blessing. Esau was angry and Jacob departed to live with his uncle Laban. When Jacob returned, many years later, the two brothers were reconciled.
How exactly does this tells us that God hates gays? I can’t see it. So I continued my search and found this:
Phelps considers himself a Christian pastor, and heads a church whose
congregation primarily consists of his own family, and whose primary mission in life seems to be to show up at homosexual gatherings, or where people gather who have given their support to the GLBT community, and places where the focus is on people with AIDS, including funerals of those who have succumbed to the disease. Known particularly for carrying mean-spirited signs, such as Queer = Death and Got AIDS Yet?, Phelps caught my attention with one sign in particular, because it contained a scripture reference. The sign read God Hates Fags, and carried the reference: Romans 9:13.
Sometimes our blessings come from the strangest places! Romans 9:13 reads: Just as it is written: “Jacob I loved, but Esau I hated.” I had to chuckle when I read the passage. Paul was actually quoting from the book of Malachi 1:2 & 3: “Was not Esau Jacob’s brother?” God says. “Yet I have loved Jacob, but Esau I have hated, and I have turned his mountains into a wasteland and left his inheritance to the desert jackals.”
I laughed out loud when I realised that Phelps had gotten his analogy a little backwards. If we apply historically stereotypical images of heterosexuals and homosexuals, Esau was the manly, macho man, the hairy hunter, the epitome of heterosexuality. Jacob, on the other hand, was gentle and quiet. He hung around the tents with the women and cooked. He was a momma’s boy. While Esau was hairy, Jacob’s skin was smooth-a trait one might call effeminate—Jacob was a poster-boy for homosexuality. In spite of the fact of Jacob’s stereotypically homosexual demeanor, it is through Jacob’s line that the Biblical story of Israel continued, not “manly” Esau’s.
Someone ought to tell Fred Phelps.